Biamonti 278 – Succession of Chords (Schm. XIV), about 1800
The musical examples and texts on this page are by Graziano Denini.
Biamonti 278 – Succession of Chords (Schm. XIV), circa 1800
This sketch appears in the notebook published by Arnold Schmitz, Beethoven – Unbekannte Skizzen und Entwürfe, Bonn, Beethoven-Haus, 1924.
This brief study for a succession of chords is preserved at the Beethoven-Haus, in a bifolio designated BH 144. More precisely, it is located at the beginning of staves 13–14, immediately following the Presto in G major (Biamonti 277) and preceding an Allegro in C major (Biamonti 279).
As with the surrounding fragments, this study was analysed by Arnold Schmitz, who writes:
“Eine rein akkordliche Wirkung stellt XIV dar.” (Sketch XIV represents a purely chordal effect.)
Analytical Notes: It is not entirely clear whether the top note in the second measure is an F or an E. Personally, given the note’s position—very close to the underlying D—I would lean toward E. However, considering the brevity of the fragment, I prefer to present both versions, leaving the decision to the listener.
- The version with F—chosen by Schmitz—is certainly more interesting, with a sound that borders on the “Wagnerian”. Yet, it introduces the error of parallel fifths between the upper voices of the staves (B♭/F – A/E).
-
The version with E, on the other hand, is more traditional in its harmonic construction.


