Opus 011 – Trio in B flat major for piano, clarinet (or violin) and cello

I) Allegro con brio – II) Adagio – III) Allegretto with Variations

Trio in B flat major for piano, (clarinet or violin) and cello op. 11, dedicated to the Countess of Thun, first half of 1798, published in detached parts (four, including one of violin in possible replacement of the clarinet) in Vienna, Mollo, October 1798; in score in Frankfurt, Dunst, after 1830. GA. no. 89 (series 11/11) – B. 11 – KH. 11 – L. I, p. 125 -N. 11 – P. 95 – T. 59

Official title: Opus 11 Trio (B-dur) für Klavier, Klarinette (oder Violine) und Violoncello Widmung: Maria Wilhelmine Gräfin von Thun-Hohenstein NGA IV/2 AGA 89 = Serie 11/11 Beiname: Gassenhauertrio (nach dem Thema des 3. Satzes)

The original manuscript is lost. Sketches of the first and second half are found on the sheets, preserved in the British Museum, of which Biamonti 154. The term “clarinet (or violin)” does not mean, in our opinion, that the Trio can be performed indifferently by one or the other instrument; but it only indicates the possibility of a fallback in the absence of the typically designated instrument, i.e. the clarinet.

It seems that the work was suggested to Beethoven by the clarinetist Joseph Beer, from whom the first idea of composing the Final Variations on the theme of the trio would also derive: Before the commitment of the work: L’amore marinaro, or II corsaro, by Joseph Weigl, (performed in Vienna on October 5, 1797), similarly to what they had already done, for the piano,  various musicians (Berner, Eybler, Gelinek, Kummel). According to Thayer-Riemann, it was instead the publisher Artaria who proposed the aforementioned theme to Beethoven, who, knowing its origin only when the composition was completed (which in reality is not too credible), would have expressed his intention (then not implemented) to write a different Finale, publishing the Variations separately.

In the first half we note the entry of the second thematic element (not repeated in the second half) for its rhythmic and harmonic physiognomy.

Of the Adagio we want to highlight, more than the adorned softness of the line, the central episode with the effective coloring of some of its tonal passages.

Of the Variations constituting the third movement, the two minors are of greater interest, from an expressive point of view, the fourth, which is collected in the short phrases of three chords each (it should be noted, with respect to the model of the basic theme, how the cadence on the tonic at the end of the first phrase has been avoided here, to form a period of greater melodic continuity) connected to each other by the suppliant melodic descents of the clarinet and cello; the seventh, in which the same instruments refer to each other with vibrant appeals, while the cadenced pace of the harmonies in the piano already marks the pace of the Funeral March for the death of a hero in the Piano Sonata op. 26.

Composition and publication: Composed between the end of 1797 and the summer of 1798. Beethoven may have known the “Gassenhauer” theme of Joseph Weigl’s opera from October 1797 onwards. The original edition in parts was published by Mollo in Vienna in October 1798. In the trio’s first movement, Beethoven returned to a musical idea he had written much earlier, probably around 1790.

About the 3rd movement: Joseph Weigl (1766-1846), “L’amor marinaro ossia II corsaro”, Commedia per musica in two acts, text taken from Giovanni De Gamerra’s play “II corsaro di Marseille” (German: “Der Korsar oder Die Liebe unter den Seeleuten”), n. 12, trio, cheerful finale to the words “Pria ch’io l’impegno “. The opera was first performed on 15 October 1797 at the Vienna Burgtheater and a total of 88 performances were performed there by January 1805. The introduction to the first movement of No. 1 seems to have been conceived only after the whole trio had already been worked out (Johnson/Fischhof, vol 1, p. 326).

(Hadamovsky/Hoftheater, Part 1, p. 8). In 1809 the opera was re-staged at the Kärntnertortheater as “Der Corsar aus Liebe” and was still scheduled in 1833 at the Theater in der Josefstadt. The melody used by Beethoven was particularly popular, finding its way into the successful Singspiel “Rochus Pumpernickel” and was used by many composers as a theme for variations, e.g. by Eybler, Gelinek, Hummel, Kozeluch and Wölfl and by Paganini (Sonata with Variations for violin with orchestra, 1828).

Dedication: Maria Wilhelmine Countess of Thun-Hohenstein, born Countess Uhlfeld, born on 12 June 1744 in Vienna, and died there on 18 May 1800, daughter of the last Imperial Count Anton Corfiz von Uhlfeld (1699-1770) and his second wife Princess Maria Elisabeth Lobkowitz (1726-1786), married to Franz Joseph Anton Graf von Thun-Hohenstein (1734-1801) from 30 July 1761. The Thun-Hohenstein Palace near the Minorite Church made Countess Wilhelmina von Thun-Hohenstein the centre of Vienna’s social and musical life. The countess had been an important patron of Mozart and Haydn and Gluck also frequented her salon. She was the mother-in-law of two of Beethoven’s patrons: one of his daughters, Maria Elisabeth (1764-1806), married Count (later Prince) Andreas Kyrillowitsch Rasumowsky (see Op. 59); the other, Maria Christiane (1765-1841), Prince Karl von Lichnowsky (see Op. 1). It is unclear whether Countess Thun-Hohenstein met Beethoven through Prince Lichnowsky or through Count Waldstein (see Op. 53), whose aunt Anna Elisabeth was her younger sister. Beethoven’s second known apartment in Vienna, the “Ogilvy’sche Haus” on Kreuzgasse behind the Minorite Church No. 35, in which he lived from the spring of 1795 to about 1799, was located in the immediate vicinity of the palace of the Counts of Uhlfeld. Lichnowsky may have arranged this arrangement (Beethoven had previously lived in a house belonging to Lichnowsky). Several members of the Thun family have subscribed to Op. 1. (Clive/Dictionary, Orel/Thun.)

First execution unknown. According to Ferdinand Ries, Beethoven was first performed by the trio at Graf Fries’ home, when the composer and pianist Daniel Steibelt was present (WegelerRies/Notizen p. 81f). However, since Steibelt was not in Vienna until the 1800s, this seems very unlikely.

Autographs and sketches

(1) 1st movement: A-Wgm, A 66, one sheet. Date: 1790 ca [!] (Johnson/Fischhof, Vol. 1, p. 255).

(2) 1.-2. GB-LBL movement, Add. ms. 29801 (“Kafka”), p. I43r and 146v. 1797 early 1798 (Johnson/Fischhof Bd. 1 S. 190), Facsimile and transcription: Kerman/Kafka.

Original Edition (gone) 1798 (ottobre). Vienna, T. Mollo and Comp., VN/PN 106. – Titolo: “GRAND TRIO / for the Pianoforte / with a [!] Clarinet or Violin, and Cello / Composed and Dedicated / To Her Excellency / Madame la Comtesse de Thunn [!] / née Comtesse d’Uhle-feld / By / LOUIS VAN BEETHOVEN / Work XIme / in Vienna at T. Mollo and Comp: on Hof N° 346. [1.:] N° 106 / [r .:] f 2.”

Riezler: «It is rare that the banality of a theme like Weigl’s, used in the Variations of the last movement, is reflected, as in this case, on the whole Trio; as if B. had consciously wanted to keep the entire work at the level of that insipid theme”. Carli Ballola: «In this work we hardly recognize the hand of the author of the Trio in C minor Op. 1. The presence of the wind instrument instead of the violin seems to have cooled the composer’s imagination; Even from a structural point of view, the work represents a step backwards: the piano is the master, keeping the other two instruments on a leash like docile poodle dogs».

On the Adagio –

Pestelli: « If the main theme sung by the cello is still rich, with its interrupted manner, in vocal impressions, the most personal nucleus of the page is in the center: it is only a short passage proposed by the piano and repeated by the two strings but wrapped in flowing arpeggios, with an almost symphonic breath or, in any case, wider than that normally contained in music created for the “camera”».

Opus 11 is part of the “Research Becomes Art” project.

A New Life for the Unknown Works of Ludwig van Beethoven: An Artistic Exploration by Bridge Trio