Opus 61, Concerto in D major for violin and orchestra
I) Allegro ma non troppo – II) Larghetto – III) Rondo
Opus 61 Concerto in D major for violin and orchestra, op. 61, dedicated to Stephan Breuning, late 1806, published in orchestral parts in Vienna, Bureau d’arts et d’industrie, August 1808; in score in Leipzig, Peters, 1861. GA. no. 29 (series 4/1) – B. 61 – KH. 61 – L. Ili, p. 58 -N. 61 – T. 130 Orchestra: 1 flute, 2 oboes, 2 clarinets, 2 horns, 2 bassoons, 2 trumpets, timpani, strings.
This concerto was written for the renowned violin virtuoso Franz Clement, who gave the first performance during an Akademie held on 23 December 1806 at the Theater an der Wien. The autograph manuscript, preserved in the Nationalbibliothek in Vienna, bears the humorous inscription: “Concerto par Clemenza pour Clement, primo violino / e direttore al teatro a Vienna / dal L. v. Bthvn 1806.” Sketches for the work are found among a number of leaves described by Nottebohm, which also contain drafts of the Fifth Symphony and the Cello and Piano Sonata, Op. 69.
The concerto, composed, by all appearances, in a relatively short period and completed only a few days before its première, bears the character of an impulsive and spontaneous creation. Soloist and orchestra are united by a gently affectionate musical sentiment; one might say that the soloist—aside from displays of virtuosity—merely echoes and elevates the orchestral phrasing into the realm of purer melodiousness. This phrasing, rich in articulation yet unambiguous in expression, forms the heart of the ensemble writing. It is this, above all, that defines the character of the first movement, in which the structural role played by the rhythm—announced from the outset by the timpani—is of particular importance, underpinning both principal thematic elements.
The height of melodic expressiveness is reached at the close of the recapitulation, when the soloist, following the ad libitum bravura cadenza, reintroduces the second theme in the lower strings, leading into the final coda.
The second movement is marked by a splendid outpouring of melody. The opening section, dominated by the orchestra with four successive statements of the theme, may at first seem somewhat static in character, despite its various instrumental colourings and the violin’s ornamental lines. Yet from this emerges an inspired song in the solo violin, before which the other orchestral voices gradually fall away, eventually leaving the soloist to sing ever more freely, unimpeded.
This spell is then abruptly broken by a brief, assertive passage that introduces the Rondo, which unfolds upon a theme both robust and graceful, dance-like in its character. Among the various episodes, one, cast in the minor mode and bearing the qualities of a romantic song, recalls, in character if not in actual material, the second movement of the String Quartet Op. 59 No. 1, as well as the finale of the String Quartet Op. 95.
Official title: Opus 61 Konzert (D-dur) für Violine und Orchester Widmung: Stephan von Breuning NGA III/4 AGA 29 = Serie 4/1 SBG X/2 („Urfassungen“ der Solostimme)
Composed, according to Beethoven’s autograph date on the manuscript score, in 1806. The solo violin part was extensively revised when the concerto was prepared for publication in 1808. The original Viennese edition, in orchestral parts, was published at the beginning of 1809 by the Kunst- und Industrie-Comptoir in Vienna and Pest; the original London edition, also in parts, appeared in August/September 1810 through Clementi & Co.
Carl Czerny wrote the following about the composition of the concerto: „Beethoven componirte dieses Concert (vielleicht sein grösstes und schönstes) in sehr kurzer Zeit für den Violinisten Franz Clement, im Jahr 1808 [!], von dem es auch, kaum 2 Tage nach seiner Vollendung, mit grösster Wirkung produziert wurde“ (Czerny/Klavierschule p. 117). Although Czerny mistakenly recalls the wrong year, it is indeed true that Beethoven composed the concerto in great haste, with little time at his disposal. Examination of the ink used in the autograph score confirms that the manuscript was written at the end of November 1806.
This left the composer with only a few weeks before the first performance, which took place on 23 December 1806. However, the only surviving sketch may have been written earlier, during Beethoven’s stay with Prince Lichnowsky in Silesia at the end of the summer (Kojima/Op. 61 p. 102). After completing a clean copy of the full score, Beethoven added an alternative version of the solo violin part, containing numerous virtuosic passages.
Shin Augustinus Kojima was able to demonstrate that, contrary to earlier views (e.g. Nottebohm/Beethoveniana II, p. 587), this version was written neither before nor immediately after the premiere with the help of Franz Clement, but only six months later, in May/June 1807, in connection with the preparation of the piano arrangement (Kojima/Op. 61, pp. 103–108; on Clement’s influence on the composition, see also Stowell/Op. 61, pp. 20–29).
Nonetheless, whether these additions to the autograph score constitute an independent second version remains a matter of debate, even though Willy Hess included it in the “original versions” of the solo part in the SBG edition. The engraving model for the original Viennese edition—containing both the solo violin and the piano reduction parts—was probably produced between June and August 1807.
The violin part appears here in a new version, incorporating both the original autograph text and the alternative passages noted therein. Questions regarding the authenticity of this version have occasionally been raised (Kaiser/Op. 61), but it is now regarded as the final version (see especially Kojima/Op. 61, Del Mar/Op. 61).
For Beethoven’s efforts to bring Opp. 58–62 to the German, Austrian, English, and French markets simultaneously, see the entry on Opus 58. In the end, however, only the Kunst- und Industrie-Comptoir in Vienna acquired all six works (in June 1807), publishing them in quick succession (numbers 580 to 596) in 1808. Yet, in the Wiener Zeitung, the publisher advertised only the piano version, issued under the same imprint and plate number (10 August 1808), while the original version for violin (together with Op. 60) was first listed in April 1809 among the works available from Breitkopf & Härtel in Leipzig.
Dedication: Stephan (Steffen) von Breuning, born on August 17, 1774 in Bonn (baptized), and died on June 4, 1827 in Vienna, was the son of Hofrat Emanuel Joseph von Breuning (1740–1777) and his wife Helene née Kerich (1750–1838), and the brother of Eleonore (1771–1841) (see WoO 40 for the dedication), Christoph (1773–1841), and Lorenz von Breuning (1776–1798). Beethoven likely became acquainted with the Breuning family in 1782 as a piano teacher for Eleonore and Lorenz. According to Franz Wegeler, Beethoven was „bald als Kind des Hauses behandelt; er brachte nicht nur den größten Theil des Tages, sondern selbst manche Nacht dort zu. Hier fühlte er sich frei, hier bewegte er sich mit Leichtigkeit, Alles wirkte zusammen, um ihn heiter zu stimmen und seinen Geist zu entwickeln.“
Stephan von Breuning pursued a legal career. He was employed by the government of the Teutonic Order in Mergentheim as an assessor from September 21, 1796, and by the end of May 1801, he was a member of the Großkapitel des Deutschen Ordens in Vienna, where he later settled. Full of joy, Beethoven wrote to Franz Gerhard Wegeler in Bonn on June 29, 1801: „Steffen Breuning ist nun hier und wir sind fast täglich zusammen, es thut mir so wohl die alten Gefühle wieder hervorzurufen, er ist wirklich ein guter Herrlicher Junge geworden der was weiß, und das Herz wie wir alle mehr oder weniger auf dem Rechten Flecke hat“ (BGA 65; see also BGA 67).
Breuning left the service of the Teutonic Order at the beginning of 1803 to work for the Hofkriegsrat, accepting the role of Hofkonzipist. In 1805 he became secretary, and in 1817 he rose to the position of Hofrat at the Ministry of War. In May 1804, Beethoven moved into Stephan von Breuning’s residence known as the “Rothe Haus.”
In July, due to unclear circumstances—presumably related to the termination of a lease agreement—a serious conflict arose between the two friends (see BGA 185f). It was only in November 1804 that Beethoven reconciled with Breuning and gifted him a miniature portrait on ivory (BGA 197; the miniature by Christian Horneman is now kept at the Beethoven-Haus in Bonn). At the end of 1805, Stephan von Breuning agreed to revise the libretto for the second version of the opera Fidelio.
In May 1806, or shortly thereafter, Beethoven set to music a translation by Breuning of the one-act play Le Secret by Jean-Pierre Solié as „ein kleines Zeichen der Dankbarkeit für die jüngst bewiesene eifrige Freundschaft Breunings in der Angelegenheit der Oper [Fidelio]“ (TDR II p. 525; see WoO 132).
In April 1808, Stephan von Breuning married Julie von Vering, daughter of Beethoven’s physician, Gerhard von Vering. Julie was a skilled pianist, and the piano version of the violin concerto was dedicated to her. The dual dedication was Beethoven’s wedding gift to the couple. However, Julie von Breuning died one year after the marriage, on March 19, 1809.
In the following years, Beethoven continued to visit Stephan von Breuning regularly and often dined with him. In 1812, Stephan von Breuning married Constanze Ruschowitz (1784–1856), who also became a friend of Beethoven. Around 1815, the relationship between the two friends cooled again; it was not until the summer of 1825 that their close friendship was restored.
In October of that same year, Beethoven moved into his final apartment in the Schwarzspanierhaus, located very close to the Breuning residence.
From that point on, Beethoven resumed regular visits to the Breuning family. Stephan von Breuning’s son from his second marriage, the future medical advisor Gerhard von Breuning (1813–1892), whom Beethoven affectionately nicknamed “Ariel” or “Hosenknopf”, later became the author of the memoir Aus dem Schwarzspanierhause (1874), which is an important source for Beethoven’s final years.
On September 26, 1826, Stephan von Breuning assumed legal guardianship of Beethoven’s nephew, Karl. During the composer’s final illness in the months leading up to his death, Stephan von Breuning and his son visited him frequently, while his wife Constanze looked after Beethoven’s household.
First performance: December 23, 1806, in an Akademie organized by the violinist Franz Clement at the Theater an der Wien. Clement was the music director of the theater and performed the concerto’s solo part.
Reviews: AmZ 9 (1806/07), 7.1.1807, column 235, and Wiener Zeitung für Theater, Musik und Poesie 2 (1807), 8.1.1807, page 27.
The review in the Wiener Zeitung für Theater, Musik und Poesie reads: „Der vortreffliche Violinspieler Klement spielte unter ändern vorzüglichen Stücken, auch ein Violin-concert von Beethhofen, das seiner Originalität und mannigfaltigen schönen Stellen wegen mit ausnehmendem Beyfall aufgenommen wurde. Man empfieng besonders Klements bewährte Kunst und Anmuth, seine Stärke und Sicherheit auf der Violin, die sein Sclave ist, mit lärmenden Bravo. […] Ueber Beethhofens Concert ist das Urtheil von Kennern ungetheilt, es gesteht demselben manche Schönheit zu, bekennt aber, daß der Zusammenhang oft ganz zerrissen scheine, und daß die unendlichen Wiederholungen einiger gemeinen Stellen leicht ermüden könnten.“
Sketches: 1st and 3rd movements: D♭-B♭, music manuscript autograph Beethoven Landsberg 10, page 64. Date: Possibly late summer 1806. Facsimile: SBB and Schmidt-Görg/Beethoven page 54, partial transcription: Nottebohm/Beethoveniana II page 533. Score: A-Wn, Mus. Hs. 17538.
Dating: “1806” (November/December). Title: „Concerto par Clemenza pour Clement primo Violino / e direttore al theatro à vienne / Dal LvBthwn / 1806“. 130 leaves (leaves 7/7b and 8/8b sewn together); no title page, 245 pages of musical text. Paper: horizontal format, trimmed at the top, approx. 23 x 32 cm. Provenance: Carl Czerny, Vienna. – Acquired with his estate in 1857 (will dated June 13, 1857: „Zwei Originalmanuskripte von Beethoven – das Violinconcert Op. 61 und die Part, der Ouvertüre Op. 115, die ich einst die Gelegenheit hatte mir zu kaufen, gebe ich der k.k. Hofbibliothek “).
First Viennese edition: 1809 (beginning), Kunst- und Industrie-Comptoir (Bureau des arts et d’industrie), VN/PN 583.
Title: „CONCERTO / pour le Violon / avec accompagnement de deux Violons, Alto, Flute, / deux Hautbois, deux Clarinettes, Cors, Bassons, Trompettes, Timballes, / Violoncelles et Basse. / Composé et Dedié / à son ami, Monsieur de Breuning, / Secretaire Aulique au service de Sa Majeste l’Empereur d’Autriche / par / Louis van Beethoven / Oeuvre 61.“









