Pages

VII) TBeethoven’s Transcription from André‑Ernest‑Modeste Grétry

Transcriptions and Studies on the Works of André-Ernest-Modeste Grétry

List of the transcriptions and studies that Beethoven made of the works of André-Ernest-Modeste Grétry (1741–1813).

André-Ernest-Modeste Grétry: The Voice of French Opéra Comique

Born in Liège in 1741, André-Ernest-Modeste Grétry was a Belgian-born composer who would become one of the defining voices of 18th-century French musical theatre. His journey from a modest childhood to the glittering salons of Paris is a tale of talent, adaptability, and charm.

Grétry’s musical roots were humble—his father was a violinist, and young André began as a choirboy at the Church of Saint-Denis. Though initially dismissed as unsuited for serious study, he proved his mettle under the guidance of local teachers and, crucially, through exposure to Italian opera. This early encounter with the vivid theatricality and melodic grace of Italian music would shape his entire career.

Thanks to a scholarship, Grétry studied in Rome from 1760 to 1766, absorbing the Italian style and composing several operettas. But it was in Paris, where he settled in 1767, that he truly found his voice. French audiences were enchanted by his ability to blend Italian lyricism with French wit and clarity. His breakthrough came with Zémire et Azor (1771), a fairy-tale opera that showcased his gift for character, melody, and theatrical flair.

Grétry became the leading figure of opéra comique, a genre that combined spoken dialogue with music. His works often tackled social themes with humor and subtle critique—Le Huron, La Fausse Magie, and Le Jugement de Midas poked fun at hypocrisy and vanity, while others explored exotic or mythological settings. He collaborated with celebrated librettists like Marmontel and Sedaine, and his music was admired by Mozart and Beethoven, who even wrote variations on his themes.

Despite occasional forays into more serious opera, Grétry remained devoted to the comic stage. His style favored graceful melodies, clear dramatic structure, and emotional accessibility over contrapuntal complexity. He believed music should serve the story—and in doing so, he helped elevate opéra comique from light entertainment to a respected art form.

Grétry died in Montmorency, near Paris, in 1813. Today, he is remembered not only for his musical innovations but for his role in shaping the emotional and theatrical language of French opera. His legacy lives on in the sparkle of his scores and the laughter and tears of the characters he brought to life.


Unidentified Aria

Unverifiable source. An autograph transcription by Beethoven, originating from the collection of Max Friedlaender in Berlin, is mentioned as no. 504 in the Führer durch die Beethoven-Ausstellung der Stadt Wien 1920 (Guide to the Beethoven Exhibition of the City of Vienna, 1920). The text of the aria, as well as the title of the work, are not indicated in the guide. Hans-Werner Küthen hypothesizes that it may be the aria of Sander taken from Zémire et Azor (cf. Küthen, annotation sheet, p. 41, note 42).

“Zémire et Azor” is a four-act opéra-ballet by André-Ernest-Modeste Grétry, inspired by the fairy tale La Belle et la Bête, and represents one of the masterpieces of 18th-century opéra comique. It premiered on November 9, 1771, at the Théâtre Royal in Fontainebleau, with a libretto by Jean-François Marmontel and choreography by Gaëtan Vestris.

Plot and characters: The opera tells the story of Sander, a Persian merchant who, upon picking a rose in the enchanted garden of the mysterious Azor, is condemned to offer one of his daughters in exchange. The young Zémire, moved by filial love, sacrifices herself and discovers that Azor, beneath his monstrous appearance, hides a noble heart. The central theme is transformation through love, with magical and moral elements.

Main characters:

  • Zémire – soprano, daughter of Sander
  • Azor – tenor, enchanted prince
  • Sander – baritone, father of Zémire
  • Fatmé and Lisbé – Zémire’s sisters
  • Ali – servant of Sander

Grétry blends Italian melody and French prosody, with simple and touching arias, duets, and choruses that reflect the rococo and pre-romantic taste. The opera also includes dances and mimed scenes, typical of the opéra-ballet. Famous is the aria “La Fauvette,” sung by Zémire, which imitates birdsong and showcases the vocal and theatrical grace of the opera.

“Zémire et Azor” was a great success at the court of Louis XV and later at the Comédie-Italienne in Paris. Queen Marie Antoinette was a patron of the work, and the opera was revived several times until the 19th century. Its blend of fairy tale, sentiment, and spectacle influenced French musical theatre and anticipated Romanticism.

The opera reflects the Enlightenment ideal of goodness hidden beneath appearances and celebrates feminine virtue and redemption. Grétry, together with Marmontel, creates a theatrical world where love transforms, beauty is moral, and music is narrative.