© Copyright 2005/2026 of the Centro Ricerche Musicali Beethoveniane (C.R.M.B.) www.lvbeethoven.it – Managers, co-authors, reviewers and curators: Luigi Domenico Bellofatto, Antonietta Cappelli, Graziano Denini, Armando Orlandi and Fiorella Romenzi. Texts, documents, research, scores, mp3, MIDI files and documents are the exclusive property of the Centro Ricerche Musicali Beethoveniane (C.R.M.B.) and their respective authors; therefore, none of these resources may be used or disclosed without the prior written authorization of the owners. The complete list of researchers, performers and collaborators of the Centro Ricerche Musicali is visible on the relevant page. Anyone wishing to contact us for consultation, to obtain a copy of the site’s resources or to collaborate with the Centro Ricerche Musicali Beethoveniane (C.R.M.B.), can make a request using the appropriate contact form. Web publishing: Aruba. Site optimized for mobile devices, tablets and PCs with a resolution of 1920 × 1440 or higher. To provide a better service to users, the site only uses technical cookies, which do not track the visitor or send personal data to third parties. These cookies do not require a prior consent banner: we mention them here anyway.
Posts
Pages
Articles – Fantasy Opus 77 by Antonietta Cappelli
Fantasy Op. 77 – A Fantastic Utopia
Or a fanciful utopia, between reality and imagination. An article by Antonietta Cappelli
The Fantasia is a musical genre free from formal constraints. Born in Italy between the Humanist and Renaissance periods, it is identified as a musical “form” intended for solo performances on keyboard or plucked instruments; it would later extend to wind and bowed instruments, as well as to instrumental ensembles. It is a brilliant, improvisatory piece that follows the evolution of performance practice and appears in two guises: either in the manner of a prelude (the art of preluding) or as an imitative (free) piece similar to the ricercare. In the late Baroque period, its imitative features disappear, monody prevails over polyphony, and it becomes adorned with virtuosic passages.
Beethoven composed his Fantasia Op. 77, a work whose description cannot be separated from the historical and personal context in which it was conceived; it is therefore necessary to recall certain events.
In the autumn of 1808, Napoleon’s brother Jérôme offered Beethoven the position of Kapellmeister in Kassel. Ludwig declined the appointment, and in order to keep him in Vienna, his three principal patrons (Archduke Rudolph, Prince Lobkowitz, and Prince Kinsky) decided to grant him an annual stipend of four thousand florins. The year 1809 marked a new phase in Beethoven’s output, one that saw him engaged in major projects and compositions (the overture to Goethe’s Egmont, the Seventh and Eighth Symphonies; the Piano Sonata Op. 81a “Das Lebewohl,” the Quartets Op. 74 and Op. 95, the Trio Op. 97, the Violin Sonatas Op. 90 and Op. 96), as well as works of various kinds, among which the present Fantasia. It is likely that this Fantasia was conceived in December 1808, as C. Czerny states, for the same concert in which the Choral Fantasy Op. 80 was premiered—namely, on 22 December 1808 at the Theater an der Wien. It begins with an improvised introduction at the piano, played by Beethoven himself. Could this very “fantasy” have given rise to the work in question? No written source tells us why it was composed or for what occasion. In any case, Beethoven completed Op. 77 in October, after the signing of the armistice and presumably during or after a stay in Hungary at the home of Count Franz Brunsvik (the work’s dedicatee) and his sister Therese. The Fantasia was published in November 1810 by Breitkopf & Härtel in Leipzig, in December 1810 by Artaria in Vienna, and in August of the same year by Clementi in London.
To interpret Beethoven’s intentions, I found it useful to consult the manuscript copy available on the Beethoven‑Haus website. When comparing the first Breitkopf & Härtel edition with later ones (including those by the same publishers), one finds differences that alter the character of certain passages. I will focus on the most striking ones. After the “Allegro con brio” section comes the first “Adagio,” followed by the descending scale and then another “Adagio.” It is precisely in this second “Adagio” that the manuscript (figure on the right) shows accents on the last eighth note of each measure—accents that I have not found in any of the editions consulted (all available on the Beethoven‑Haus website).
Breitkopf & Härtel, first edition, 1810 (posthumous corrections to the printing are visible)
Artaria Edition of 1813
Manuscript (preserved at the Beethoven Haus) fig.1
Manuscript (preserved at the Beethoven Haus) fig.2
These accents, if omitted, fail to convey the recitative character that Beethoven intends, just as the “picchettato” markings found in the sections presented below. They appear only in the earliest editions; in later ones they are reduced to simple staccatos. Here too the character changes, because in the manuscript (as is evident) Beethoven seems to indicate the specific wrist motion required to obtain the desired sound: dry and decisive.
This “picchettato” is also marked beneath the final note of the piece, clearly showing that Beethoven wanted an ending without hesitation—dry, forceful, and unequivocal.
A sextuplet which, in many editions, becomes a double triplet (at tempo it will be difficult to perceive whether one is playing triplets or sextuplets… what matters is to lean on the first note of each group of six semiquavers, because this recreates the same melody as the opening theme—hidden, and not highlighted even by Beethoven himself).
This piece is an “atypical” composition within Beethoven’s catalogue, and even his contemporaries noted that the composer was searching for new harmonies and moving away from classical models. In 1813, the reviewer of the Viennese newspaper Allgemeine Musikalische Zeitung wrote: “There is often talk of new works by Beethoven, but anyone even partially familiar with the compositions of Mr. Beethoven will view this new work from two perspectives: as entirely original in its harmonies, forms, and modulations; and as very difficult to perform.”
The Beethoven who diligently recorded his sketches is also the improviser who kept his ideas in his mind and brought them to life when needed. Many scholars have detected this improvisatory vein in his sketches. J. Kerman, in the introduction to the Kafka Miscellany, emphasizes that Beethoven’s annotations reveal “improvisations on paper.” R. Kramer, on page 5 of his Beethoven’s Compositional Process, writes: “[…] We may attempt to establish a general distinction between formal improvisation, as a form of public performance, and private improvisation, which is an innate action in any compositional act. Of this second type, Beethoven’s sketches—the fraction of the process that was written down—constitute a precious legacy.”
Had this Fantasia not been written down, we would never have been able to hear or perform it, as has often happened with many improvisers of the past. This is the case with Mussorgsky’s “Black Sea Storm,” a piece mentioned by several contemporaries but for which no score exists. The composer used to perform it in his concerts, but he never wrote it down, as Alexandra Orlova reports in Musorgsky Remembered.
Let us now turn to the specific features of the Fantasia Op. 77 and attempt to identify the characteristics that distinguish it:
- It has no fixed key but is a continuous sequence of modulations.
- Free and agile improvisation, interrupted by large chords.
- Melodic lines in constant tonal evolution.
- Predominance of dissonant sonorities.
- If we consider this piece merely as a display of virtuosity, we lose its true nature. There are many expressive passages that verge on the “recitative” (for example, the “Adagio” sections, including the ending).
- A continuous search for contrasting elements in dynamics and notation. The aim is to astonish both the listener and the pianist encountering the score for the first time.
- The “chromatic” compositional style recalls that used by J. S. Bach in the Chromatic Fantasia and Fugue BWV 903, and which Beethoven himself explores in Op. 39 (the two chromatic preludes).
- I would define the piece as a “chromatic fantasia” followed by a theme and variations (Allegretto); we cannot assign a single tonal center to the entire work because it is a “modulating becoming.”
- Despite its heterogeneity, it forms a unified whole because the slow sections act as a binding agent. The first part consists of contrasting, modulating themes, and from the Allegretto onward begins the final section, which closes with the Adagio and the contrary‑motion scales that seem to recall the initial bichromatic scales, ending with an octave leap on the tonic.
-
After a tonal excursus through the various sections of the Fantasia, Beethoven arrives at the Allegretto in B major—and not by chance. Although it has five sharps in the key signature, it is the most comfortable and stable key for the hands. In my view, given the passages of agility and the various technical demands, the choice of B major is anything but accidental.
The first fifteen measures feature the bichromatic scales, ascending and descending, together with the poco adagio, sweet and expressive. A third idea then appears: Allegro, ma non troppo, in a dance‑like style which, with its final dominant‑seventh chord (preceded by a leading‑tone seventh), initiates an Eingang made of broken arpeggios (typical of Bach’s writing) leading into the Allegro con brio, evoking a Hungarian rhapsodic style. This latter section and those that follow (Adagio / Presto / più presto / Adagio) put the performer to a severe test: passages of virtuosity alternate with lyrical and expressive ones.
After the central section, the music arrives at the final idea: a carefree Allegretto rich in variations. In the last page the bichromatic scale patterns return, and not by chance: Beethoven “closes the circle,” and to recall the opening idea he assigns contrary‑motion scales to both hands. This final page is extremely intricate from a technical standpoint and employs rich harmonies that produce full sonorities; in some passages one plays with all ten fingers simultaneously, reminiscent of the large chords of S. Rachmaninoff and far removed from classical models. And then, the final note is extremely detached and marked—almost “punched.”
[…] Here Beethoven pushes a particular principle—the principle of disjunction—to the extreme, and he would surely smile at our well‑intentioned attempts to find the structural axis of the piece […]. The core of the work is the absence of a structural axis. There seems to be no other way to judge the Fantasia than as a deliberate attempt to highlight the disruptive elements of music. Hugh MacDonald, “Fantasy and Order in Beethoven’s Phantasie Op. 77,” in Edgard Olleson (ed.), Modern Musical Scholarship, Oriel Press, Stockfield 1980, p. 145.
Studying this piece has fascinated me because it allowed me to understand how Beethoven’s creative act might have been perceived in its performative phase. My initial impression was one of bewilderment: extremely rapid ascending and descending scales, slow and meditative sections alternating with agitated and unstable ones, the presence of fermatas and silences. These last two elements in particular convey the sense of an idea in continuous evolution, of that emotional inventiveness that only the human mind can produce, using breaks just as we do in speech: silences and suspended notes function like breaths that facilitate the articulation of discourse and make it expressive.
There are two “moments” that brought to mind two famous works by composers who came after Beethoven: the Adagio (after the rhapsodic section) and the presto / più presto.
The Adagio features repeated notes that evoke the ticking of time, or—as in Chopin—the “raindrop” of the Prelude Op. 28 No. 15. The presto / più presto is an idea we find in several of Beethoven’s works, particularly in the first movement of the celebrated Sonata Op. 57, the Appassionata. Later, the idea would be taken up by S. Rachmaninoff in his youthful Prelude in C‑sharp minor Op. 3 No. 2, known as the “Bells of Moscow,” precisely in the central section marked Agitato and followed by an accelerando, as shown in the figure.
Immagine del manoscritto di Chopin, presa da Wikipedia.
These two examples demonstrate the posthumous influences of Beethoven’s way of composing and presenting music. Op. 77 is a disruptive way of introducing sonic ideas which, in my view, conveys a precise message: the past, the present, and the future are intimately connected. The apparent disjointedness of this work disappears as soon as one delves into its study; that is to say, the tastes of classical Vienna were changing, and the sociopolitical disorder I mentioned earlier was opening new perspectives. Moreover, Beethoven was a mature musician, and all his studies—as evidenced by his sketches—led him to dare and to seek the new. How could one ignore the historical context?
The Fantasia is a portrait of Vienna at the time, of its “capricious” and frivolous bourgeoisie. Beethoven once again astonishes everyone and bids farewell to the wider public with this enigmatic work; and, as many of his biographers note, after his grand performances there often followed a great burst of laughter.
The Opus 77 Fantasy is part of the “Research Becomes Art” project.
A New Life for the Works of Ludwig van Beethoven: An Artistic Exploration by the Pianist Professor Antonietta Cappelli



















































