Unv. 2 – Biamonti 73. Youthful symphony in C major, 1794 – early 1795
The musical examples on this page are by Adrian Gagiu.
This refers to several sketches mentioned by Nottebohm (Nottebohm, II, pp. 535–536), by Shedlock (*MT*, June 1892, p. 332), and more recently by Stein, developed around a theme that clearly anticipates the finale of the First Symphony, and at the same time shows certain similarities with the opening movement of the Piano Concerto in C major, Opus 15. Nottebohm initially considered them as belonging to that very symphony; later, however, he revised his view and attributed them to an earlier, separate symphony that Beethoven is thought to have conceived between 1794 and early 1795, but eventually abandoned. Shedlock came to the same conclusion. Additional sketches, discovered on the final page of the manuscript for the “Rondò a capriccio” for piano, Opus 129—uncovered in 1945 and closely analysed by Hertzmann—lend further support to this view, differing overall from the finale of the First Symphony.
Origin: the symphony was conceived and sketched from 1794 in Vienna, then likely developed further during Beethoven’s concert tour in the spring of 1796, and again upon his return to Vienna later that year. The dating of the sketches is based solely on contextual references to other works and the type of paper used. Beethoven likely began work on the symphony as early as 1794, as suggested by the sketches found on the final autograph page of Op. 129. According to Jos van der Zanden (Zanden/Ingharese), the “Rondò a capriccio”, Op. 129, was itself composed in 1794. Gustav Nottebohm had already proposed this dating based on the sketches from Beethoven’s studies with Albrechsberger (Nottebohm/Beethoveniana II, p. 229).
Beethoven continued to work on the symphony until mid-1796, including during his concert tour to Prague, Dresden, and Berlin. Some of the sketches were made on paper he acquired only during his stay in Berlin (sketches 1 and 6, as well as folios 81/82 of sketch 2). This indicates that he was still actively engaged with the work in May and June 1796—perhaps hoping for a performance in Berlin. All remaining sketches on Viennese paper date from before this journey (Johnson/Fischhof, vol. 1, p. 465f). Only folio 59 of the “Kafka” Miscellany (sketch 2) was written on paper used by Beethoven in 1796/97. This is the sole indication that he may have returned to the symphony after his return to Vienna, before finally abandoning the project.
Douglas Johnson, in contrast to van der Zanden, dates the earliest surviving sketches to the second half of 1795, suggesting that Haydn’s return from England and the preparations for his grand academy in December 1795 served as inspiration for the symphony.
According to the sketches, the Allegro of the first movement was to be preceded by a slow introduction. Most of the surviving material relates to this opening movement. The slow movement is an Adagio in F major, occasionally reimagined as an Andante in different keys, followed by a minuet and trio. Beethoven planned the finale in 6/8 or 12/8 time (for the layout of the sketches and their elaboration, see in detail: Douglas P. Johnson, Beethoven’s Early Sketches in the Tischhof Miscellany: Berlin Autograph 28, PhD dissertation, University of California, 2 vols., Ann Arbor, Mich., 1978, vol. 1, pp. 785–1037).
In composing his First Symphony, Op. 21—also in C major—Beethoven eventually returned to this earlier preparatory work: the opening of the rondo theme from the finale corresponds with the principal theme conceived for the first movement of the earlier symphonic project (Raab/NGA I/1, p. 149).
Sketches:
(1) First movement (slow introduction and Allegro), plus three further movements (Adagio in F, Minuet and Trio, Finale in 12/8): Re-Sib, Mus. SM. autogr. Beethoven 28 (“Fischhoff”), pp. 9, 13–14, and 16–17. Dated: May/June 1796. Facsimile of folio 16v: Johnson/Tour 1796, p. 37. Complete facsimile: SBB. Transcription: Johnson/Fischhof, vol. 2.
(2) First movement (slow introduction and Allegro), plus three further movements (Adagio in A, Minuet and Trio, Finale in 6/8): GB-Lbl, Add. Ms. 29801 (“Kafka”), pp. 56–57, 59r, 71v, 127v–128v, and 158–159, possibly also pp. 81–82 and 97r. Dated: 1795; pp. 81–82: May/June 1796; p. 59: late 1796. Facsimile and transcription: Kerman/Kafka.
(3) A-Wgm, A 75 II, fol. 9/c, fol. 50.1r. Dated: 1794/95. Ronge/NGA XIII/1, vol. 1, p. 233. Nottebohm/Studien, p. 202.
(4) Slow movement (Andante in C): F-Pc (in: Pn), Ms 79, fol. 1r. Dated: early 1796? Facsimile: Gallica.
(5) First movement (Allegro) and slow movement (Andante in C major): US-NYpm, Lehman Deposit (autograph of Op. 129), fol. 4v. Dated: 1794 (Zanden/Ingharese). Facsimile and transcription: Hertzmann/Op.129, pp. 176–177.
(6) First movement (Coda) and slow movement (Andante): I-BGi, double folio. Dated: May/June 1796. Facsimile and transcription: Holschneider/Bergamo.
(7) First phrase? (Attribution uncertain): D-BNba, NE 96. Dated: 1795? Facsimile: DBH/online.
Bibliography:
Holschneider/Bergamo. – Johnson/Fischhof, vol. 1, pp. 461–469. – Douglas P. Johnson, *Beethoven’s Early Sketches in the ‘Fischhof Miscellany’: Berlin Autograph 28*, PhD dissertation, University of California, 2 vols., Ann Arbor, Mich., 1978, vol. 1, pp. 785–1037. – Müller-Reuter/Beethoveniana. – Nottebohm/Beethoveniana II, p. 228ff. – Raab/NGA I/1, p. 149.






