WoO 42 Sechs deutsche Tänze (Allemande in the first edition), for Piano and Violin

“Deutsche für die zwei Comtessen Thun um andern Leuten darnach auf dem Kopfe zu tanzen, und dabey zu denken an ihren sie verehrenden Ludwig von Beethowen (sic!) Prag 1796.”

WoO 42 Six Allemandes for Piano and Violin, 1795 – 1796, published in Vienna, Maisch, July 1814. GA. No. 308 (series 25/45) – B. 171 – KH. (WoO)42 L. IV, Pages 343/8 P. 59, Thayer 184 Biamonti 112.

The title of the original edition, “Six Allemandes pour le Pianoforte avec accompagnement d’un violon”, explicitly indicates the complementary nature of the violin part, as was also the case in other earlier works, such as the Variations on “Se vuol ballare” by Mozart, WoO 41. The original manuscript is lost. Sketches for the first and third Allemandes can be found on a sheet noted by Nottebohm, which also contains fragments of the aria “Ah, perfido!” and other notes bearing resemblance to thematic elements from the first movement of the String Quartet in B flat major, Op. 18 No. 6. Additionally, we may note a closer similarity with the Sonatina for Mandolin and Piano in C major. These are small, unpretentious pieces. Traces of both the first and last Allemande can be found in the lively peasant gathering of the Pastoral Symphony.

In the manuscript that has survived, the first reprise of the I Deutsche Tanz is missing an entire bar, specifically the fifth measure, which should be a repeat of the initial one.

In the second reprise of the Trio in the III Deutsche Tanz – measure 4, right hand of the piano – in the final movement, we find a G in the manuscript; this is surely an error, as it should be a C, as in the beginning of the reprise.

A title page and 6 staves of manuscript in oblong format. The name in the dedication may refer to Countess Marie Wilhelmine Thun-Hohenstein, née Countess Urfeld (1744-1800), wife of Franz Joseph, Count Thun-Hohenstein. The second “Contessina” could be her sister Maria Elisabeth (1747-1791), wife of Count Georg Christian Waldstein. The three daughters of the Count, who had a friendly relationship with Beethoven, had all been married for quite some time.

The eldest, Elisabeth, had been married to the Russian Consul, Prince Rasumosky, since 1788; the second, Maria Christiana, was the wife of Prince Karl Lichnovsky; the third, Karoline, had been married since 1793 to Richard I Mead, second Earl of Clanwilliam, later Lord Guilford, an Irish statesman.

Beethoven would therefore never have referred to them as “Contessine”. Their mother was one of the most beautiful women in Viennese society during the last two decades of the 18th century. Fräulein von Kissow (later Frau v. Bernard), mentioned in Beethoven’s recollections, is remembered as “a very eccentric woman”. Very close to Mozart, she is cited in the writings of Wurzbach (volume 45, page 23), who quotes two enthusiastic judgments from English tourists Wraxall and Swinburne, who visited her. The daughters were famous for their beauty, which was painted by the artist Füger.

Although surviving only in a copy, this manuscript is significant for Beethoven research, also for the unique form of the dedication, which offers a new perspective on the friendly relationship between Beethoven and the Thun family.

WoO 42 – Deutsche per Violino e Piano – Manoscritto (Fischhof foglio 43-v)

Friedrich Heinrich Füger – Die Gräfinnen Elisabeth, Christiane und Marie Karoline von Thun – 2144 – Österreichische Galerie Belvedere

Origin and Publication: Composed between February and April 1796 in Prague. The original edition was published by Maisch in Vienna in July 1814. Beethoven wrote the Sechs deutschen Tänze (“Six German Dances”) in Prague during a concert tour that also took him to Dresden, Leipzig, and Berlin, for „Die zwei Comtessen Thun um anderen Leuten darnach auf dem Kopfe zu tanzen“ (see Johnson / Tour 1796, page 26). It is unclear to which branch of the noble Thun family such a dedication could refer, since at the time Countess Wilhelmine von Thun was over 60 years old and her daughters – all already married – had adopted their husbands’ surnames. (One daughter, Maria Christiana, was the wife of Prince Lichnowsky, with whom Beethoven had travelled in Prague). Much can be speculated about this unorthodox and humorous dedication, which has survived in a copy by an obscure scribe. It might have been intended for a young Thun of the third generation (Johnson / Fischhof vol. 1, p. 417). It is noteworthy that in the list of subscribers to Beethoven’s Three Piano Trios, Op. 1, we find „S. E. la Comtesse de Thun, née Comtesse Kollowrath“, who had committed to purchasing 22 copies of Beethoven’s Opus 1. The first performance of the work is not known, but it likely took place in a private setting within the Thun family in Prague in 1796.

Sketches: D-B, Mus. SM. Autograph 28 by Beethoven (“Fischhof”), page 43 versus; Dating: from February to April 1796 (Johnson / Fischhof vol. 1, pp. 416 and 421), facsimile: SBB / Microfiches. Transcription: Johnson / Fischhof vol. 2, pp. 124f.

In A-Wn, there is a transcription of the dances titled „Deutsche, für die zwei Comtessen Thun um andern Leuten darnach auf dem Kopfe zu tanzen, und dabey zu denken an ihren Sie verehrenden Ludwig von Beethowen, Prag 1796“ (Mus. HS. 8977).

First Edition: 1814 (July). Vienna, Louis Maisch, VN / PN 512. Title: “6 Allemandes / pour le Piano forte / avec accompagnement de Violon / par / Louis van Beethoven. / A Vienne chez Louis Maisch” – Horizontal format, title page (unprinted back) and 3 pages. – Piano title for No. 1: “Deutsche / Nro 1.” – Announcements for the release of the work: Wiener Zeitung 30 July 1814 and 8 January 1816.

A transcription for piano exists: 1855. Vienna, P. Mechetti (Wiener Zeitung 11 May 1855). In: “Les Colibris. 36 Morceaux favoris transcrits dans un style facile pour Piano par W[enceslas] Plachy […]”, Op. 109, Cahier 3, PN 4908. According to KH, this piece could be just No. 6 with some modifications to the musical text.

Literature: Brandenburg / NGA V / 2 S. Vllf. – Johnson / Fischhof vol. 1, pp. 92-102, 415-417, 421. – Johnson / Tour 1796. Cataloguing: Thayer / 1865 No. 184 (p. 121). – Nottebohm / 1868 p. 152. Hobochen No. 585-586. – Weinmann / Maisch p. 29. – Weinmann / Mechetti S 137f.