Carlo Alberto Pagni Beethovenian Breviary – Preface –
Carlo Alberto Pagni Beethovenian Breviary
Milan, May 2005
“Music is a moral law. It is the essence of order and elevates all that is good, just, and beautiful, of which it is the invisible form.” — Plato
“Shame upon the blind who took Beethoven for deaf!” — Wilhelm von Lenz
“A deaf musician! Can we imagine a blind painter? Yet we do know the seer who became blind. The deaf musician resembles Tiresias, who, blind to the vision of the phenomenal world, contemplates with the eye of the soul the center whence all phenomena proceed. Undisturbed by the clamors of life, Beethoven remains alone, intent upon his inner harmonies, and from those depths he still speaks to that world which has nothing more to say to him.” — Richard Wagner
“One could not simply go on forever with Mozart. It required a deaf man to make us hear something new…” — Julien Green
To the artists: Der Menschheit Würde ist in eure Hand gegeben, bewahret sie! Sie sinkt mit euch! Mit euch wird sie sich heben!
Human dignity is placed in your hands, guard it! It declines with you! With you it shall rise! — Friedrich Schiller
“The only thing of importance in the world is music: music, books, and a few paintings. I shall found a community in which no one will marry, unless perchance one falls in love with a symphony of Beethoven.” — Virginia Woolf
Denis Arnold & Nigel Fortune, Preface to The Beethoven Companion
“Modern statistical methods could no doubt calculate whether more words have been written about Beethoven than about any other composer; such methods, however, do not help us to grasp the fact that [Beethoven] has provoked the most varied comments, of every kind and in every possible shade, more than any other musician, though Mozart is a very close competitor. The list of commentators begins with musicologists and musical critics: but novelists and politicians, philosophers and poets, all have swelled the flood of words, employing an image, sometimes mythical, for their own ends. In spite of a literature that already presents a formidable challenge to the bibliographer, it may be said with certainty that there will be no check to this growth.
It may come as a surprise, if not a real shock, to discover how much remains to be done before a complete portrait of the musician emerges. It is difficult to think that Beethoven’s daily existence could provide the researcher with new surprises; while the continuous study of his sketchbooks offers a way of knowing his working method, much still remains to be studied concerning his published musical texts. Better knowledge of the musical fabric of the first decades of the nineteenth century is also necessary. And to this must be added the study of the modes of execution of Beethoven’s tempi.”
Purpose of this book
The aim of this book is not to discover anything new about Beethoven. In this book there is, in truth, absolutely nothing new. It is rather a sort of collage of material that has been published, from the time when Beethoven was still alive down to our own days. Yet many of these publications are either unobtainable, or difficult of access, or written in foreign tongues.
I have done nothing more than gather, from all these writings—read over more than half a century and listed in the Catalogue of Books and Writings Consulted


