WoO 208 (Formerly Hess 19) Quintet (unfinished) in E flat major for oboe, three horns and bassoon
I) (Frammento) – II) Adagio mesto – III) Minuetto Allegretto
Hess 19 Quintet (unfinished) in E flat major for oboe, three horns and bassoon, c. 1796; completed in 1862 by L. A. Zeltner; published by W. Hess with the above completion in Mainz, Schott, 1954; and according to the original manuscript in the seventh issue of the Supplemente zur GA., 1963. B. 302 – H. 19 – T. 282.
The original manuscript, incomplete, from the Artaria collection and once held at the Preussische Staatsbibliothek in Berlin, was lost after the last war. A photocopy of it exists in the Beethovenhaus archive. The first movement is entirely missing its opening section and development; it begins with the transition to the recapitulation and then proceeds regularly until the conclusion (see the errata later). The Adagio is complete. The Minuet stops at the nineteenth bar (ninth of the second section). It is unclear whether there was a fourth movement. The work is notable for the ensemble of instruments used, especially the three horns, which form the centre of its timbre and expressive gravity, from which the oboe part blossoms into more flexible melodic phrases, while the bassoon predominantly supports the bass line. With Zeltner’s completion, the work has had some performances even in recent times. However, the reconstruction of the missing parts, although admirable and thorough, must always be regarded as a surrogate for the lost original. It is generally accepted that this Quintet corresponds to the entry in the Thayer catalogue, where No. 282 mentions an “incomplete Sextet for oboe, clarinet, 3 horns, and bassoon (Allegro and Minuet).” In the manuscript, in fact, a blank line was left between the oboe and the first horn parts, to which an annotation referring to the clarinet in B-flat is added in the Adagio and the Minuet; however, the author only intended to suggest the possibility of substituting one instrument for another, not the introduction of a new instrumental part.
This Quintet has not survived in its entirety. Barry Cooper Says: «(…) the first movement (4/4 the beginning has been lost) – Adagio mesto (2/4)- Menuetto Allegretto (third movement incomplete)»[1] and a fourth movement is certainly missing, as it is very unlikely that it will end with a Minuet. It is probably the Quintet of which Haydn referred in the letter[2] to the Elector of Bonn, Maximilian Franz, on 23 December 1793, believing it, together with other works, to have been composed by Beethoven on Viennese soil, in fact it was music already composed the year before in Bonn.
The Quintet was completed by Leopold Alexander Zellner in 1862 and was performed for the first time in that year. Its musical quality suggests that it could have been an opera of great interest but, unfortunately, we cannot know how it would have been in its entirety. On the fragment of the work, Giovanni Carli Ballola writes: «(…) The overwhelming predominance of the three horns and the bassoon over the delicate voice of the oboe gives this unusual composition a certain dark colour, which enhances the meditative tones of the Adagio.(…)».[3] Cesare Fertonani writes: « That it has survived in incomplete form is truly a pity: both for the uniqueness of the instrumentation, centred around the ensemble of three horns, and for the musical interest evident in what remains of the composition (…).
What survives of the opening Allegro begins from the final part of the development section, but it is with the recapitulation that one can truly appreciate the style of writing that characterises the work. In the first thematic group, followed by the transition, the three horns are answered by a section in which the unison Tutti signals initiate an elaborate texture where the oboe at times traces florid passages, at others joins the bassoon in dialogue with the horns. The second thematic group is formed by a gentle exchange between the horn and the oboe, sealed by the close of the recapitulation and then by the fading coda, which echoes the main theme of the movement.
Of undeniable charm is the Adagio mesto, where the ensemble of second and third horns and the bassoon provides a timbral backdrop that is evocative and emotionally responsive to the clear lyrical quality of the oboe and first horn; the form is extremely simple, with the first section then repeated and varied. Of the Menuetto. Allegretto, only a few bars remain: the repeated first part, and the beginning of the second. [4]
[1] Barry Cooper: The Beethoven Compendium. Clarendon Press. From James F: Green: The new Hess catalogue of Beethoven’s works. Zecchini Editore
[2] Letter no. 13. Ludwig van Beethoven: Epistolario 1783 – 1807 Volume I. A cura di Sieghard Brandeburg. Skira editore
[3] From the magazine “Amadeus” n. 191: Beethoven e gli strumenti a fiato. Primavera spumeggiante. Giovanni Carli Ballola. De Agostini periodici.
[4] Cesare Fantoni: Guida all’ascolto del cd AM 191- 2 allegato alla rivista “Amadeus” n. 191. De Agostini periodici
Official title: WoO 208 Quintett (Es-dur) für Oboe, drei Hörner und Fagott Widmung: -NGAVI/1 AGA-SBGVII/4 (Hess 19)
Composition and Publication:
Composed in Bonn before Beethoven left for Vienna in November 1792, possibly revised in Vienna the following year. The first edition of the surviving fragment was published posthumously in 1963 as part of the SBG by Breitkopf & Härtel in Wiesbaden. (photo). A version completed by Leopold Alexander Zellner and edited by Willy Hess was published by Schott in Mainz as early as 1954.
The wind quintet has survived only fragmentarily, with incomplete first and third movements, and a complete second movement; it is unclear whether a fourth movement ever existed. It may have been among the works that Joseph Haydn sent to Elector Maximilian Franz in Bonn on 23 November 1793 as evidence of the progress made by his pupil Beethoven (BGA 13). However, the Elector complained in his reply:
„Da indessen diese Musik, die Fuge ausgenommen, von demselben schon hier zu Bonn komponirt und produzirt worden, eher diese seine zweyte Reise nach Wien machte, so kann mir dieselbe kein Beweis seiner zu Wier. gemachten Fortschritte seyn“ (BGA 14).
The Elector’s claim that the works were conceived, written, and performed in Bonn is supported by the inventories of the Bonn court chapel (I-MOe, Cat. 53. I–II), in which the wind quintet is also listed (Riepe/Hotkapelle p. 110).
In another analysis, the paper of the autograph score dates to the Viennese period, and Douglas Johnson dates it to the second half of 1793 (Johnson/Fischhof vol. 1 p. 105). Apparently, Beethoven revised the quintet during lessons with Haydn.
In the autograph score, a line for clarinet was left blank between the oboe and the horns. This is why the quintet was described as a “sextet” at the auction of the “Beethoven estate” and listed as such by Alexander W. Thayer (Thayer/1865 no. 282).
Johnson also conjectured that a sextet was never actually planned, but that the clarinet was intended as an alternative to the oboe (Johnson/Artaria p. 223f; see also Voss/NGA VI/1 p. 368). In the 1827 auction catalogue, the manuscript appears under the heading “Skizzen, Fragmente und zum Theil unvollständige Werke” (no. 69), so the work was likely already preserved in incomplete form.
In 1862, Leopold Alexander Zellner (1823–1894) completed the surviving fragment by restoring the exposition and recapitulation of the first movement and creating a development section using Beethoven’s motifs […].
The completion of the third movement, on the other hand, was carried out by adopting the form of minuets. (Hess/Wo0208). The first edition, published by Willy Hess in the SBG, uses Zellner’s additions to complete the work.
The first performance is unknown, but it likely took place in Bonn before Beethoven departed for Vienna in November 1792. The first performance of the version completed by Leopold Alexander Zellner took place on 28 February 1862 in Vienna (Hess/Wo0208).
WoO 208 (Formerly Hess 19) Quintet (unfinished) in E flat major for oboe, three horns and bassoon
Transcription by Willy Hess for oboe and piano –
I) Allegro – II) Adagio mesto
Beethoven’s Forgotten Gem for Oboe and Piano
Aside from the beautiful Quintet Op. 16, Beethoven didn’t write any original works for oboe and piano. So the obvious solution was to adapt one of his chamber pieces for winds, preserving the oboe’s original solo line while arranging the remaining parts for piano. There’s really only one work where this can be done with artistic integrity: the Quintet in E-flat major for oboe, three horns, and bassoon, composed during Beethoven’s early years in Vienna (Hess 19 / WoO 208).
In this piece, the oboe truly leads—except, of course, when it rests. Transcribing the other four parts for piano was relatively straightforward. In the Adagio, it was possible to follow the original note for note, while the longer Allegro required a slightly freer approach to make it pianistically satisfying. The oboe part remains faithful to Beethoven’s writing, with one exception: from the upbeat of bar 12 to the middle of bar 15, it’s enriched with a lovely melody borrowed from the first horn.
Sadly, the Quintet survives only as a fragment. Pages are missing at both the beginning and the end. What remains starts near the end of the first movement’s development section; the second movement is complete, while the third breaks off after bar 19. It’s unclear whether Beethoven intended a minuet followed by a fourth movement, or a more expansive rondo finale—either way, completing the work was impossible.
That said, Viennese music director L. A. Zellner skillfully reconstructed the opening of the first movement. Remarkably, listeners would never guess that the surviving music begins at bar 158! This version was first performed in Vienna on February 28, 1862. For the third movement—which is omitted in this edition—an improvised finale was added. In 1954, I prepared the first publication of the Quintet for B. Schott & Sons in Mainz.
This transcription of the first two movements offers more than just a glimpse into a little-known Beethoven work. It also adds two expressive and rewarding pieces to the rather limited repertoire for oboe and piano.
Willy Hess












